People, I’ve never been a huge fan of cupcake wedding cakes. I can appreciate their cuteness and everything, but they’re just not my style.

So you can imagine my horror when my mother demanded that we serve cupcakes at our wedding. Why couldn’t we do something weird and different, like homemade pies, or (my idea) a giant mountain of Belgian waffles and French toast? Well, apparently she and her friends still want a modicum of tradition at our wedding, so the cupcakes are my way of honoring that.

…but since I’m doing cupcakes, I’m gonna do them my way. I spent about half a day researching and found an incredible cupcakery in Seattle called Look Cupcakes. Oh, and did I mention that they FILL their cupcakes? Yeah. I’ll let you marinate on that for a while.
So here’s my vision: we’re doing mini-cupcakes (3 minis equal one big’un), because I want to have some cool flavors for my guests to eat. Plus mini-cupcakes might be the most darling thing I’ve ever seen in my life. The European-style meringue buttercream frosting will be different shades of yellow and white, and the cupcakes will be displayed at varying levels on square pedestals, rather than on a traditional cupcake tower. We’re talking 600 mini-cupcakes here, people. I’m not messing around.
But enough about that; you probably want to hear the flavors I chose. Drumroll, please…
The Feather Boa (coconut cream cake, mojito cheesecake filling, vanilla swiss meringue buttercream), Summer in Your Hand (lemon cake with raspberry cheesecake filling and raspberry meringue buttercream), a custom chai cake with salted caramel filling and hazelnut meringue buttercream and a vegan Emperor’s New Grove (vegan chocolate cake, Valencia orange vegan ganache and Valencia orange vegan buttercream.)
I made up that custom one with chai cake, caramel filling, and hazelnut buttercream – hopefully Rhienn (the owner of Look Cupcakes, whose blog you can read here) will name the flavor after me.
People, here’s why you want cupcakes at your wedding: the tasting. Ohhhh, the tasting. Such a traditional, delicious, 100 percent yummy and decadent wedding experience. Rhienn does her tastings a little differently by “deconstructing” the cupcakes and bringing you a plate of cake flavors with a plate of filling and buttercream flavors. TELL me this doesn’t make your stomach lurch with yearning:


The cake flavors shown above are (clockwise from the top left, which I’ve always wanted to say because it sounds like a magazine): lemon cake, vanilla cake with chocolate ganache filling, and coconut cream cake. The fillings (clockwise from the top left) are: raspberry cheesecake, mojito cheesecake, chocolate ganache, chocolate meringue buttercream, hazelnut buttercream, Swiss vanilla buttercream, and my personal favorite – salted caramel. Rhienn and her peeps make everything from scratch using all-natural ingredients. No artificial flavoring or chemicals to speak of. So that caramel you see up there – that’s from a vat of caramel that she makes herself. Swoon.
Here’s the aftermath, about five minutes after these photos were taken:


Immediately after I took that second photo I grabbed my spoon and cleaned the plate without any accompanying cake. I gotta tell you: a plate of buttercream is a wonderful thing indeed.
What are your thoughts on cupcakes vs. wedding cakes vs. alternative wedding desserts? What would you do, or what did you do for your own wedding?

17 comments
Comments feed for this article
June 30, 2009 at 12:59 am
Courtney
WOW, and I thought my mini-muffins were cool, HOLY EFF, I’m inspired to get to baking! I LOVE ALL THINGS MINI! The chai concoction sounds way good. WAY good. I’m on her website now, I’m in Portland, so knowing she’s a mere 4 hour drive away …
June 30, 2009 at 1:10 am
mmclaughlin
Sounds delicious!! One of my friends did something similar with several variations of cheesecake (3 tiers of full-sized cheesecake with little bite-sized cheesecakes surrounding them, instead of a traditional cake). Those flavors for your cupcakes sound incredible! Now I’m craving cupcakes!! mmmmm….
June 30, 2009 at 1:34 am
Betsy
I would totally do a cupcake cake for my wedding if we were having it here (in Pittsburgh), but since it’s in our dinky little hometown the options are limited. I am trying to sway my fiance to agree to a giant cookie table though… the wedding is 6 days before Christmas!
June 30, 2009 at 2:05 am
Wiggs
THAT. IS. AWESOME. Do itttt!!! And then tell me ALL about it.
June 30, 2009 at 2:19 am
whitneyinchicago
The combo that you designed sounds amazing! I like the cupcake idea since you get to have so many different flavors! I might miss the whole, cutting the slice business though.
June 30, 2009 at 4:24 am
Laura
Holy Yum! What a great idea. If (When) I ever get married, I am totally doing filled cupcakes.
June 30, 2009 at 4:31 am
Susan
I think the cupcake idea is cute! I’m definitely going to have an ice cream cake as my wedding cake…probably from Dairy Queen! Unless I opt for an ice cream sundae bar…complete with different flavors of ice cream, whip cream, and toppings galore! I can’t decide which would be better…
June 30, 2009 at 5:36 am
Rhienn
WOW, that’s some incredible looking cake up there!
Your blog is awesome. And I’m totally honored that you love our stuff.
(Also, your phone takes really good pictures!)
See you soon.
June 30, 2009 at 7:17 am
Sarah
I had mini-cakes at my wedding…lemon & raspberry torte and banana & buttercream, they were 3 round layers with filling in between. They were a hit and way easier to deal with then having to cut up a regular sheet cake. I don’t think you’d need 600 even if they are mini though!
June 30, 2009 at 12:47 pm
Andrea [bella eats]
YUM!!! I think the cupcake idea is totally cute, and probably would have gone that route had we gotten married in the town where I live. But being a DIY-er and one to pile ridiculous amounts of stress on myself, I probably would have attempted to make them myself, which would have ended in a disaster.
We had an amazing vanilla cake with raspberry and white chocolate ganache filling, with white chocolate buttercream frosting. So delicious. But, since we got married in New Orleans, we ALSO had individual banana’s foster served. YUM.
June 30, 2009 at 1:44 pm
Amy
I was just writing about dessert at my wedding yesterday, lol! I think we’re going with the homemade pies…..but I love your cupcakes. They look SO amazing and drool-worthy.
June 30, 2009 at 2:49 pm
Beverly
My wedding cake was a cupcake tree and it was a HUGE hit with our guests. It was very easy to “grab and go” and they didn’t need forks or plates. Several people told us they liked it because they didn’t feel “guilty” going back for seconds, since there were not “cake slicers” handing it out. I love alternatives to traditional wedding cakes. I love giant cookie bars and candy bars… all the colors are so pretty in the containers!
June 30, 2009 at 8:03 pm
Christina
(new stalker here, delurking – HELLO!)
I am fully supportive of non-traditional desserts. We had a selection of macaroons (mint chocolate, raspberry rosewater and coconut), a chocolate torte, apple financier and a lemon tart. A bit non-committal for a wedding, but colorful and tasty.
We made the initial cut in the chocolate torte then “fed” each other a bite of a macaroon. The marriage has been happy so far (9.5 months – wooo!), so I guess it worked out ok!
June 30, 2009 at 9:51 pm
Wiggs
Oooo, congrats on your new marriage! I love having a selection of flavors/treats for the guests – everyone gets a chance to choose their fave! (and welcome to the light, my little lurker…I love when people come out of hiding!)
July 1, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Angela
OMG- this is possibly the coolest thing ever!!!! This is going to be a huge hit!!!!
The flavours sound amazing!
July 1, 2009 at 5:44 pm
Ariel
I had cupcakes instead of a traditional cake at my wedding last summer in part because we didn’t want to make a big deal out of the whole cake-cutting thing. Also, the rest of the food at our wedding was cocktail party/finger-food fare so cupcakes fit with the theme. We got ours from Cupcake Royale (so tasty!) and it worked out really well. I think the best part was eating leftover cupcakes for breakfast the next day!
July 2, 2009 at 5:16 am
Madelin
Love cupcakes! My sister does amazing cup cake wedding cakes!